Giants - Steelers Preview

Sunday, 4:15 on FOX


Watch CBS Videos Online

Restoring My Faith In Eli

Every once in awhile I question the competence of Eli Manning. Why? Because he can be so good one week and so erratic the next. From here on in, whenever that happens, I will click on this video....

As Eli Goes...So Go the Giants

Eli Manning threw 3 INTs on Monday. When that happens, the Giants usually get blown out....two of his INTs were while the Giants were driving downfield and the other was a miscommunication with Plaxico Burress. That is no mystery since Burress and Manning have not worked with each other that muchthis season due to injuries and Burress' suspension.

Giants Finally Lose One

Until Monday's deflating defeat on MNF to Cleveland, the Giants had not lost since their legendary battle with New England in Week 17 last season and they had not lost on the road since Week 1 of last year.

That all changed on Monday when the Browns inexplicably kicked the living crap out of Big Blue 35-14 on national tv....

RECAP


Watch CBS Videos Online

Keys To Repeating

With the first game out of the way, and the Vince Lombardi Trophy restored back to its proper shelf in the lobby, the public has seen a preview of what they can expect from the Giants in 2008.

One game against the listless Redskins does not a season make, though. There is much to improve on if they are to repeat - or even come close to repeating - as Super Bowl champions.

1. Eli Manning must not put the ball up for grabs. He did it again last night under pressure. When will this very bad and costly habit end? He is the reason why 'experts' are calling the Giants a fluke.

2. The coaches must not divert from the game game for the sake of doing so. The Giants were absolutely steamrolling the Redskins with their running game. So why, for the sake of Allie Sherman were they trying to establish the passing game with two-score lead in the 3rd quarter? That has to stop. The only thing that will accomplish is allowing opponents to get back in games.

3. The Giants must be able to relax at home and trust the fans. They won their first home game in almost 11 months, but they didn't look comfortable at all in the 2nd half. For some reason they lose their fire during homes games, especially in games in which they get an early lead.

4. Kevin Boss and Ahmad Bradshaw must be in the game plan. Boss was absent last night and Bradshaw did not play. Boss needs to catch a pass early to get him in rhythm. Bradshaw needs to get some reps to level out the running game. He has the ability to take it to the house, so why not let him?

5. R.W. McQuarters should not be returning punts. How old is he, anyway? Sinorice Moss and Bradshaw both have more speed. What don't I know here?

6. Kenny Phillips should be starting soon. Michael Johnson isn;t a bad player, but let's see what the kid has. He made some plays last night, which is a good sign that he may be ready.

The Giants will probably find ways to iron out these problems over the course of the season. They have the ability to repeat - all the ingredients are there.

The pass rush and overall defense looks like one of the league's best. The offensive line is consistent, the receiving corp is deep and the running game is tops. They need to improve on special teams, cut down on dumb penalties and stupid mistakes (usually made by Eli). If Boss and the TEs can get more involved in the offense, this team will play deep into January and possibly February again.

Giants Are Still The Team to Beat

The New York Giants have been classified by the mainstream NFL media as a fluke.

The last time I checked, a fluke was type of fish. In some regions they are called 'doormats', in others, the summer flounder. They also are voracious predators with very sharp teeth.

If that is the case, then a fluke is outwardly docile but extremely dangerous up close.

Bingo. They finally got it right. This Giant team looks like any other team in the league on the surface, but deep down they are the most dangerous team in the NFL. Read on.

Last season, the Giants came out of 'nowhere' to win the Super Bowl. 'Nowhere'? The Giants weren't exactly the Tampa Bay Rays. This is a team that had qualified for the playoffs the previous two seasons. Granted, they were inconsistent, but they were 8-8 and 11-5 in the previous two seasons. Their 2007 record should have been at least 12-4, not 10-6. Let's face it. There was no love for these Giants from the start.

The media loves the Dallas Cowboys and the San Diego Chargers. They loved their penchant for talent accumulation and their sexy potential. The Giants possessed those qualities but the media never beat the drum for them. So, when an 'unknown' player by the name of David Tyree made an impossible catch to jettison this team past the unbeatable Patriots, the media played it up as if it were a fresh angle.

If you are true football fan, you would know that David Tyree is one of the game's most talented and hardest working players. He did in that game what he is known for - making game-changing plays. He was far from a secret weapon.

Going into this season, the Giants have been given little to no chance of repeating. The Cowboys are heavily favored. The Eagles, for some reason, are also predicted to finish ahead of the Giants. Neither one of these teams has won a Super Bowl in the new millennium and neither has shown much heart in their post-season efforts.

The myth is that the Giants have lost too many key players to make a run at the NFL Championship. The reality is they might be a better team without those players.


Issue: the Giants will miss Michael Strahan and Osi Umenyiora. Will they? Strahan still had some gas in his tank, but realistically he was not the Strahan of old. Umenyiora had 13 sacks in 2007, but to be fair 6 of those came in a game against an inexperienced LT and an immobile Donovan McNabb. They will be replaced by the real MVP of Super Bowl XXII - Justin Tuck - and former first rounder Mathias Kiwanuka, who is a bigger, faster, stronger version of Umenyiora. The pass rush may actually be BETTER in 2008.

Issue: the Giants linebackers and secondary are sub par. Really? Antonio Pierce is the centerpiece at MLB, and at last glance he was one of the league's best. He will be surrounded by young players the Giants have been grooming - Gerris Wilkerson and Bryan Kehl. Remember those names. As for the secondary, the Giants have been building through the draft. In 2005, their top pick was Corey Webster. In 2007, it was Aaron Ross. This year, the team spent their first two choices on Kenny Phillips and Terrell Thomas. They are five of the 10 defensive backfield players on the Giants' 2008 roster. They have quantity and quality at all positions now.

Issue: Super Bowl MVP or not, Eli Manning has still not turned the corner. That, to me, means that his best days are still to come. That's a good thing. The truth is that Manning has finally realized that he has to be fastball pitcher in the NFL. He has to throw spirals - especially at home. In week 17 last season, he found that fastball. Since then, the Giants have been a force to be reckoned with.

This is a team that also has consistency at offensive line, an excellent WR corp and an unstoppable running game with Brandon Jacobs, Derrick Ward and Ahmad Bradshaw.

So keep picking Dallas and Philadelphia and Minnesota to represent the NFC in the Super Bowl.

I'll stick with the Giants.

Roster Finalized; Simms May Be Added

The Giants announced their final roster cuts on Saturday, releasing promising WR Brandon London and 6th round pick, QB Andre Woodson.

In other developments, the team signed veteran kicker John Carney to spell Lawrence Tynes until he heals. They also kept only 2 QBs - Eli and David Carr, paving the way for Chris Simms, who was finally let go by Tampa this week.

Here is how the roster will look for now:

Offense: 25

Quarterback (2): Eli Manning, David Carr.

Running Back (5): Brandon Jacobs, Derrick Ward, Ahmad Bradshaw, Reuben Droughns,
Danny Ware.

Fullback (1): Madison Hedgecock.
Wide Receiver (6): Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, Steve Smith, Mario Manningham,
Domenik Hixon, Sinorice Moss.

Tight End: (3): Kevin Boss, Michael Matthews, Darcy Johnson.

Offensive Line: (8): Shaun O’Hara, Rich Seubert, Chris Snee, Kareem McKenzie, David Diehl, Kevin Boothe, Adam Koets, Grey Ruegamer.

Defense: 25

Defensive Line (8): Justin Tuck, Mathias Kiwanuka, Fred Robbins, Barry Cofield,
Renaldo Wynn, Dave Tollefson, Jay Alford, Rodney Leisle.

Linebackers (7): Antonio Pierce, Gerris Wilkinson, Danny Clark, Chase Blackburn,Zak DeOssie, Bryan Kehl, Jonathan Goff.

Defensive Backs: (10): Aaron Ross, Corey Webster, James Butler, Michael Johnson,
Kevin Dockery, Sam Madison, R.W. McQuarters, Sammy Knight,
Kenny Phillips, Terrell Thomas.

Specialists: 3

Punter (1): Jeff Feagles.

Kickers (2): Lawrence Tynes, John Carney.

Osi Injures Knee In Loss To Jets

Giants to Learn Extent Of Injury On Sunday

Giants May Have Struck It Big With Phillips

Rookie Wowing Team Thus Far

Sam Madison, the elder statesman of the Giants is awestruck by the team's first round draft choice, Miami safety Kenny Phillips. The similarities to another Miami safety - the late Sean Taylor - are stunning.

"He looks like him, plays like him, even wears his pads like him" said Madison in a radio interview Tuesday in Albany. That is good news for the Giants - and bad news for the rest of the league, many who had thought the Giants' secondary would be weaker without Gibril Wilson, who departed via free agency.

According to my eyes he looks like a winner. YaHoo Sports likes him, too: Kenny Phillips had a spectacular opening game and should win the starting free safety job by the time the season starts. He had six tackles, broke up a pass and anticipated an end-around play to be there at the line of scrimmage when the ball-carrier got there.

Phillips is the physical player the Giants have lacked in the middle of their secondary. The past two seasons the team had gotten exposed by players like Terrell Owens, Jason Witten and Chris Cooley. GM Jerry Reese used his first two selections in the NFL Draft this past April to address the weakness. He brought in Phillips and another physical player - USC CB Terrell Thomas - to face off against those division rivals.

By drafting Phillips, Reese not only replaces Wilson with a better player, he gives the vaunted Giant defense another weapon. This is a huge development for Giants fans and an fans of the other 3 NFC East teams. While the NY and national media have fled the Giants camp for Hofstra, to cover every move Brett Favre makes, the Giants may have made the best move of all.

That defense that was last seen throwing Tom Brady around like a rag doll may be better than ever come opening day.

Giants Looking At Pennington

Ousted Jets QB Drawing Interest

Don't know why the Giants are looking at Chad Pennington, but they are. After David Carr and Anthony Wright both strutted their stuff last night in Detroit and they drafted Andre Woodson in April, quarterback would not be a position the Giants would be looking to fortify.

But they are. The Giants have confirmed they are interested in all and every able body that comes along.

"We take a look at everybody that's out there," GM Jerry Reese said after the Giants' preseason-opening 13-10 loss to the Lions. "That includes him."